(#ulink_477e4baa-2156-5f5f-8a42-3ac007b21f1f)
Magdalen College,
Oxford,
May 3rd, 1951.
Dear Sir,
I have read Mr. Watt’s essay on Robinson Crusoe
(#ulink_2db89756-f7fc-5a78-9461-c7db22120715) with great interest and almost complete agreement. But what does he mean when he says that the myths of Midas and the Rheingold are ‘inspired by the prospect of never having to work again’ (p. 104)? Surely the point of the first story is that Midas’s golden touch brought starvation: and the point of the second that the gold carried a curse. If the gold in either story has an economic signification at all (which might be questioned) the meaning must be less banal than Mr. Watt suggests.
(#ulink_02cdd3ad-29ad-5126-9111-1befd3e4caf8)
Yours truly,
C. S. Lewis
TO GEORGE SAYER(W):
Magdalen College
Oxford
5/5/51
I had no notion of all this oriental background to you–barbaric pearl & gold.
Glad to hear the illness was not serious. Any chance of a night or week-end later? I needn’t say how welcome you’d be.
J.
Love to both from both.
TO AN ANONYMOUS GENTLEMAN (P): TS
REF.236/51
Magdalen College,
Oxford.
12th May 1951.
Dear Sir,
If I knew a little more about the subject I should have been very glad to introduce your edition of the Psalms. But whatever I tried to say, I should come up against my ignorance. The right person to do it would be Sister Penelope, C.S.M.V., St Mary’s Convent, Wantage, who understands both their religious use, and something of their history.
With all good wishes,
yours faithfully,
C. S. Lewis
TO VALERIE PITT (BOD):
(#ulink_65687a04-21e3-514a-8704-8339dedef71e)
Magdalen College
Oxford
15/5/51
Dear Miss Pitt—
It seemed to me after I’d got to bed that in my anxiety to prod a silent meeting into some semblance of debate I may have given the impression that I overlooked what Farrer
(#ulink_ae89c21e-206f-543f-92c3-b5cd6218495e) rightly called the richness of yr. paper. The parts of it we wd. really like to have discussed were those least suitable for the Socratic. I hope you will continue to pursue the subject. All good wishes
C.S.L.
TO MARY MARGARET MCCASLIN (W): TS
REF.238/51.
Magdalen College,
Oxford.
15th May 1951.
Dear Mrs. McCaslin,
Thank you for your kind letter of the 11th.
A book of reference tells me that John Flavel came from Dartmouth and kept a private school.
(#ulink_b3abb9d2-7c0f-59ba-b82f-15d583ba2efb) I have never heard of him before nor seen his books. But I have no difficulty in believing that he may be excellent. The past is full of good authors whom the general literary tradition has ignored and whom one only finds by chance. There is a great element of chance in fame. With all good wishes,
yours sincerely,
C. S. Lewis
TO GEORGE ROSTREVOR HAMILTON (BOD):
Magdalen